Constitutional Petition for Defeating Delays


If there is one problem which can be considered the BIGGEST problem facing our civil justice system, it is DELAY.

Recently, there has been much talk of judicial reform coming from the SC lately which is a good thing. Taking a cue from the Supreme Court's public statement, my colleagues and I have filed a Petition to the Supreme Court of Pakistan under Article 184(3) of the Constitution. We have challenged the SC to match its words with action. Here's a copy of the Petition:


Petition for Defeating Delays (click to read Petition)






The crux of our petition is that we have urged the SC to exercise judicial activism to clean its own backyard.

We have pointed out that perhaps, the three most important things needed for defeating delay in the civil justice system are: (i) fixing mandatory time-limits for different kinds of cases; (ii) imposing 'costs' on those litigant and lawyers who cause delay or file frivolous case; and (iii) punishing witnesses who commit perjury, ie submit knowingly false affidavit or record such testimony.

Under the scheme of our Constitution, it is the judiciary - and not government or Parliament - which is responsible for doing something about these matters. Please see Articles 202 and 203 of Constitution and S. 123 CPC which delegates power to High Courts to make procedural law and control courts; S. 35 and 35A of CPC (and Costs of Litigation Act 2017) which empowers courts to impose Costs; and S. 195 Cr.PC which gives judges exclusive power to prosecute Perjury.

The fact is that thus far the judiciary doesn't have much to show on these issues. We're asked it to do something about it.

We're also pushing for data-driven performance accountability of the judiciary. ​The people of Pakistan ​should be able to ​judge the performance of the court system is by looking at ​numbers​. Citizens have a right to know the average time it takes for a case to go from start to end - or shelf-life statistics. At the moment, the judiciary does not collect or publish these numbers. We've urged the judiciary to regularly collect and publish vital judicial statistics. There can be no​ accountability or constructive critique of the judiciary without these numbers.

The Petition was filed on 1st February, 2018. In the first hearing on 19th February, 2018, the Supreme Court was pleased to issue notices to all the High Courts and the Federal and provincial governments. However, there been little progress since then.

PLEADINGS 

Amended Memo of Petition

Reply of Islamabad High Court - Part 1

Reply of Islamabad High Court - Part 2

Reply of Lahore High Court

Reply of High Court of Sindh - Part 1

Reply of High Court of Sindh - Part 2


SUMMARY OF THE PETITION SUBMITTED TO COURT via CMA on 14th September







AMICUS BRIEF OF SALAHUDDIN AHMED, ADVOCATE SUPREME COURT

In the first week of October, 2018, Mr. Salahuddin Ahmed amicus curiae has filed a 16-page brief fully supporting the contentions of the petition.

MEDIA SUMMARY OF THE PETITION 

Judicial Activism for Judicial Reform. Op-ed in The News by Umer Gilani. 16th February, 2018.
https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/281549-judicial-activism-for-judicial-reform

A BACKGROUND ARTICLE 

The Pace of Justice. Op-ed in The News by Umer Gilani. 31st December, 2016 https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/175638-lahore-beat-karachi-in-u16-event

MEDIA COVERAGE OF THE PETITION

11th February, 2018
https://tribune.com.pk/story/1631854/1-sc-hear-petition-seeking-judicial-reforms-next-week/

19th February, 2018
https://www.dawn.com/news/1390299

20th February, 2018
https://tribune.com.pk/story/1639327/1-need-revamp-judicial-system-cjp/

1st April, 2018
https://www.dawn.com/news/1398871

8th April, 2018
Internal Reform. Op-edin Dawn by Basil Nabi Malik. https://www.dawn.com/news/1400273

23rd June, 2018
https://tribune.com.pk/story/1740451/1-no-witness-prosecuted-perjury-lhc/

28th June, 2018
https://tribune.com.pk/story/1744716/1-unable-put-house-order-says-cjp-judicial-reforms/

30th June, 2018
Judicial Reforms. Editorial by Dawn. https://www.dawn.com/news/1417007

11th July, 2018
https://tribune.com.pk/story/1754829/1-pbc-discuss-cjps-suo-motu-proceedings-july-28/

5th August, 2018
https://tribune.com.pk/story/1773598/1-no-one-prosecuted-perjury-three-years-shc/